Services
    Practice Groups
  • Antitrust Counseling & Litigation
  • Bankruptcy, Insolvency & Creditors’ Rights
  • Capital Markets & Securities
  • Commercial Transactions
  • Corporate & Transactional
  • Corporate Compliance & Governance
  • Data Security & Privacy
  • Employee Benefits
  • Environmental
  • Executive Compensation
  • Finance
  • Franchising
  • Immigration
  • Insurance Recovery
  • Intellectual Property
  • International
  • Labor & Employment
  • Litigation, Trials & Appeals
  • Mergers & Acquisitions
  • Personal Injury & Products Liability
  • Public Finance
  • Public Law
  • Real Estate
  • Safety & Health – OSHA/MSHA
  • Tax
    Industries
  • Aviation
  • Banking & Financial Services
  • Cable Television, Internet & Media
  • Commercial & Resort Real Estate
  • Construction
  • Food & Beverage
  • Golf, Resorts & Private Clubs
  • Government Contracts
  • Healthcare
  • Media & Publishing
  • Nonprofit & Tax-Exempt Organizations
  • Oil & Gas, Energy & Natural Resources
  • Religious Organizations
  • Space Law
  • Sports Law
  • Telecommunications
    Private Client
  • Criminal Defense/White Collar Defense
  • Estate & Tax Planning
  • Family Law
  • Farm & Ranch
  • Privately Held Businesses
  • Residential Purchases, Sales & Construction
  • Services
  • Professionals
  • News & Events
    • Current News and Events
    • Events and Registration
    • In The Media
    • Publications & Advisories
    • Speaking Engagements
  • About the Firm
    • About the Firm Page
    • History
    • Inclusiveness
  • Blog
  • Careers
    • Careers at Sherman & Howard
    • Lawyers
    • Business Professionals
    • Law Students
  • Affiliations
    • Interlaw
  • Offices
  • Contact
  • Menu

  • Services
  • Professionals
  • News & Events
    • Current News and Events
    • Events and Registration
    • In The Media
    • Publications & Advisories
    • Speaking Engagements
  • About the Firm
    • About the Firm Page
    • History
    • Inclusiveness
  • Blog
  • Careers
    • Careers at Sherman & Howard
    • Lawyers
    • Business Professionals
    • Law Students
  • Affiliations
    • Interlaw
  • Offices
  • Contact
  • Search Professionals
    • Name
    • Service
        Practice Groups
      • Antitrust Counseling & Litigation
      • Bankruptcy, Insolvency & Creditors’ Rights
      • Capital Markets & Securities
      • Commercial Transactions
      • Corporate & Transactional
      • Corporate Compliance & Governance
      • Data Security & Privacy
      • Employee Benefits
      • Environmental
      • Executive Compensation
      • Finance
      • Franchising
      • Immigration
      • Insurance Recovery
      • Intellectual Property
      • International
      • Labor & Employment
      • Litigation, Trials & Appeals
      • Mergers & Acquisitions
      • Personal Injury & Products Liability
      • Public Finance
      • Public Law
      • Real Estate
      • Safety & Health – OSHA/MSHA
      • Tax
        Industries
      • Aviation
      • Banking & Financial Services
      • Cable Television, Internet & Media
      • Commercial & Resort Real Estate
      • Construction
      • Food & Beverage
      • Golf, Resorts & Private Clubs
      • Government Contracts
      • Healthcare
      • Media & Publishing
      • Nonprofit & Tax-Exempt Organizations
      • Oil & Gas, Energy & Natural Resources
      • Religious Organizations
      • Space Law
      • Sports Law
      • Telecommunications
        Private Client
      • Criminal Defense/White Collar Defense
      • Estate & Tax Planning
      • Family Law
      • Farm & Ranch
      • Privately Held Businesses
      • Residential Purchases, Sales & Construction
    • Office
      • Albuquerque
      • Aspen
      • Colorado Springs
      • Denver
      • Las Vegas
      • Phoenix
      • Reno
      • Scottsdale
      • St. Louis
      • Steamboat Springs
    • Title
      • Associate
      • Member
      • Paralegal
  • Professionals

Supervisor’s Racial Epithets are “Hellish” Enough

By Chance Hill A defendant-employer won summary judgment on a racially hostile environment claim. The district court reached back to old cases and said the employee-plaintiff had to show the work environment was “hellish” to be actionable. On February 20,…
Read More

2019-02-22T11:24:49-07:00
Posted on February 22, 2019

By Chance Hill

A defendant-employer won summary judgment on a racially hostile environment claim. The district court reached back to old cases and said the employee-plaintiff had to show the work environment was “hellish” to be actionable. On February 20, 2019, the Seventh Circuit disagreed.

The Seventh Circuit rejected the “hellish” standard, stating that a plaintiff’s evidence need not amount to the equivalent of the Ninth Ring or a descent into the Inferno. It also underscored that the district court’s analysis was flawed because it overlooked the difference between a co-worker uttering racially offensive remarks as opposed to a supervisor’s use of such toxic language—the latter of which is much more serious, according to the appellate court. The Seventh Circuit added that this concern is magnified when supervisors make derogatory and humiliating comments directly to the employee in question, compared to situations in which the employee may hear offensive comments secondhand.

The literary lessons here are twofold: (1) Dante’s Inferno did not set the bar for impermissible harassment, and (2) Marshall McLuhan’s famous phrase “the medium is the message” applies with great force to workplace harassment—toxic language coming from a co-worker is bad, but toxic language from a supervisor is terminal.

Fred Gates v. Board of Education of the City, No. 17-3143 (7th Cir. 2019)

Posted in Discrimination, Racial Discrimination | Tagged Hostile work environment, summary judgement
  • Services
  • Professionals
  • News & Events
    • Events and Registration
    • In The Media
    • Publications & Advisories
    • Speaking Engagements
  • About the Firm
    • History
    • Interlaw
    • Inclusiveness
  • Blog
  • Careers
    • Lawyers
    • Business Professionals
  • Offices
  • Contact

Copyright 2000-2019 Sherman & Howard L.L.C. All rights reserved. Privacy Policy | Terms of Use | Site Map +

Email Disclaimer

Sending an email to Sherman & Howard or to one of its lawyers, paralegals, or employees does not create an attorney-client relationship between you and Sherman & Howard, and the receipt of the email does not indicate Sherman & Howard’s willingness to discuss forming an attorney-client relationship with you. If you are not already a client of the firm, you should not provide us with confidential information without first speaking to one of our lawyers. If you provide such information before we confirm that we are willing and able to consult with you about becoming a client, we may not be in a position to treat that information as confidential or privileged, and we may be able to represent a party who is adverse to you, even if the information you submit to us could be used against you.

Please indicate below that you have read the foregoing notice about email communications and that you wish to send an email under the conditions we have set out above.

I have read and agree with the above disclaimer and wish to Email Sherman & Howard.

×

Email Disclaimer

Sending an email to Sherman & Howard or to one of its lawyers, paralegals, or employees does not create an attorney-client between you and Sherman & Howard, and the receipt of the email does not indicate Sherman & Howard’s willingness to discuss forming an attorney-client relationship with you. If you are not already a client of the firm, you should not provide us with confidential information without first speaking to one of our lawyers. If you provide such information before we confirm that we are willing and able to consult with you about becoming a client, we may not be in a position to treat that information as confidential or privileged, and we may be able to represent a party who is adverse to you, even if the information you submit to us could be used against you.

Please indicate below that you have read the foregoing notice about email communications and that you wish to send an email under the conditions we have set out above.

I have read and agree with the above disclaimer and wish to Email this attorney.

×